Authors/Duns Scotus/Reportatio parisiensis

From The Logic Museum
Jump to navigationJump to search

The reportatio parisiensis is the collective name given to transcriptions of the lectures on the Sentences given by Scotus in Paris. A reportatio is a student report or transcription of the original lecture of a master. A version that has been checked by the master himself is known as a reportatio examinata. (The Lectura, by contrast, are not notes made by students, but rather the lecture notes made by the master himself). There are a number of reportationes of Scotus's lectures at Paris. Scotus himself personally examined a reportatio of his lectures on Book 1, the Reportatio examinata. Note that what the Wadding edition calls Reportatio 1 is actually Book 1 of the Additiones magnae (see below).

  • On Book 1:
    • Reportatio 1A (the Reportatio examinata)
    • Reportatio 1B edition: Paris 1517
    • Reportatio 1C (Reportatio cantabrigiensis) edition: not yet edited
    • Reportatio 1D edition: not yet edited
    • Reportatio 1E (34) edition: not yet edited
  • On Book 2:
    • Reportatio 2A edition: Wadding 11
    • Reportatio 2B (a shorter version and the principal source for Additiones 2) edition: not yet edited
  • On Book 3:
    • Reportatio 3A edition: Wadding 11
    • Reportatio 3B, 3C, 3D edition: not yet edited
  • On Book 4:
    • Reportatio 4A edition: Wadding 11
    • Reportatio 4B edition: Paris 1518

A third collection of questions on books I and I of the Sentences is called the Additiones magnae. These were made by Scotus' secretary, William of Alnwick, and are probably a summary of the longer reportatio of the Paris lectures.

Editions

  • Allan B. Wolter and Oleg V. Bychkov (ed., transl.)John Duns Scotus. The Examined Report of the Paris Lecture: Reportatio I-A, Latin Text and English Translation. Vol. 1. St. Bonaventure, N.Y.: Franciscan Institute, 2004. [Prologue and distinctions 1–21.]
  • Allan B. Wolter and Oleg V. Bychkov (ed., transl.) John Duns Scotus. The Examined Report of the Paris Lecture: Reportatio I-A, Latin Text and English Translation. Vol. 2. St. Bonaventure, N.Y.: Franciscan Institute, 2008. [Distinctions 22–48.] * Klaus Rodler, Die Prologe der Reportata Parisiensia des Johannes Duns Scotus: Untersuchungen zur Textüberlieferung und kritische Edition. Mediaevalia oenipontana 2. Innsbruck: Studia, 2005. [Prologues of Reportatio I A, Reportatio I B, Reportatio I C, and of William of Alnwick’s Additiones Magnae]
  • Allan B. Wolter and Marilyn McCord Adams. “Duns Scotus’ Parisian Proof for the Existence of God.” Franciscan Studies 42 (1982): 248–321. [Latin-English; contains Reportatio I A d. 2 q. 1–3.]
  • Timothy Noone, “Scotus on Divine Ideas: Reportatio Paris. I–A, d. 36.” Medioevo 24 (1998): 359–453.
  • Joachim R. Söder (ed., transl.), Johannes Duns Scotus. Reportatio Parisiensis examinata I 38–44 = Pariser Vorlesungen über Wissen und Kontingenz: lateinisch, deutsch. Herders Bibliothek der Philosophie des Mittelalters 4. Freiburg im Breisgau: Herder, 2005.

Wadding

See also